I think the devil is in the execution details on this— I'd prefer to detail some copy & comps for these states before you start lifting code, does that work for you?

This is constantly tripping me up. I want to see what devices a user has; i go to their MemberInfo, and look blank because i'm in an unencrypted room. I want to verify them; similarly.

@nadonomy do you agree MemberInfo should show the same whether it's in an encrypted room or not?

@nadonomy do you agree MemberInfo should show the same whether it's in an encrypted room or not?

Yup. I'm not sure if it's as binary as displaying the exact same thing though, will review the micro copy and figure out what other changes (if any) are needed.

this continues to massively trip me up - c.f. the related mess in #12850 (comment)

Having looked at the user journey in more detail, when viewing users in unencrypted rooms, we need to vary the copy in 3 places, detailed below. We also shouldn't need to modify the current decoration logic.

@jryans @manuroe @BillCarsonFr what's the best way to track this cross-platform? Are you ok to echo the issue across respective repos?

1. Viewing profiles

E2E: Messages in this room are end-to-end encrypted.
Non E2E: Messages in this room are not end-to-end encrypted.

2. Before verifying

After clicking [Verify], before clicking [Start Verification]

E2E:

Messages in this room are end-to-end encrypted.

Your messages are secured and only you and the recipient have the unique keys to unlock them.

Non E2E:

Messages in this room are not end-to-end encrypted.

In encrypted rooms, your messages are secured and only you and the recipient have the unique keys to unlock them.

3. After verifying

E2E: Verify all users in a room to ensure it’s secure.
Non E2E: In encrypted rooms, verify all users in a room to ensure it’s secure.

@jryans @manuroe @BillCarsonFr what's the best way to track this cross-platform? Are you ok to echo the issue across respective repos?

At the moment, our approach is each team filing issues in their repos as needed and labelling for the story. It does take some vigilance to avoid things falling in the cracks, so something to ponder for the future.